How municipal bonds are different from other bonds
Types of municipal bonds
Who should consider buying municipal bonds
How to determine the equivalent yield on municipals
Are "double-exempt" bond funds better than "single-exempt" funds?
When to never invest in municipals
Municipal bonds are offered by state and local governments
Municipal bonds offer something that US Treasury and corporate bonds can't
Interest payments are free from federal income tax
However, because of the tax-free nature of the interest, municipal bonds yield less than other bonds of comparable maturities and credit worthiness
Municipal bonds are also generally safer than corporate bonds since many municipal bonds are backed up by the local government's taxing authority
General obligation bonds are generally the safest form of municipal bond
- The municipality can and must use its taxing authority to pay off the bonds
- Used to fund infrastructure like sewers or to simply fund budget deficits
Revenue bonds are more speculative
- Used to fund airports, stadiums and the like
- Usage fees from these facilities are used to repay the bonds
- If enough people don't use the facilities, the bondholders don't get paid
Private activity bonds
- Used to fund projects with a commercial interest
- May be subject to tax through the alternative minimum tax
Single-exempt bonds are issued by states or municipalities outside your state
Single-exempt bonds are exempt from federal income tax but subject to state income tax
Double-exempt bonds are issued by states or municipalities inside your state
Double-exempt bonds are exempt from federal income tax and state income tax
Only interest income on municipals is tax-free
Still have to pay capital gains
Higher income people who receive Social Security benefits face an indirect tax on their numicipal bond income
Remember that municipal bonds yield less than comparable bonds because of tax-exempt income
So only invest in municipal bonds if the after-tax yield is attractive for the maturity and degree of credit risk
This depends on your tax bracket
For single-exempt bonds, or if your state has no income tax, use your marginal federal income tax rate
Federal tax rates are 15, 28, 31, 36 and 39.6 percent
If you're in the 15 percent bracket, you probably shouldn't invest in municipal bonds
For double-exempt bonds, use your federal income tax bracket plus your state income tax bracket
State marginal income tax rates are typically 5 percent
The before-tax equivalent yield is the yield of a taxable bond such that you would be indifferent, on an after-tax basis, of buying the taxable or tax-free bond
Equavalent yield = (Quoted yield on municipal bond) / (1 - marginal tax rate)
Examples
Single-exempt bond, 28 percent federal tax bracket, bond yields 6 percent
Equivalent yield = 6 percent / ( 1 - .28) = 8.33 percent
At this tax bracket, you would be indifferent to buying a taxable bond yielding 8.33 percent and buying a municipal bond yielding 6 percent, if the maturity and credit risk were comparable
Double-exempt bond, 31 percent federal tax bracket, 5 percent state bracket, bond yields 7 percent
Equivalent yield = 7 percent / ( 1 - .36) = percent = 10.94 percent
Before-tax yield
After-tax equivalent yield for indicated tax bracket
15% bracket
28% bracket
33% bracket
36% bracket
3.0% 3.5% 4.2% 4.5% 4.7% 4.0 4.7 5.6 6.0 6.3 5.0 5.9 6.9 7.5 7.8 6.0 7.1 8.3 9.0 9.4 7.0 8.2 9.7 10.4 10.9 8.0 9.4 11.1 11.9 12.5
To create the greatest amount of tax avoidance, it's best to invest in double-exempt bonds
But buying individual bonds can be a hassle and expose yourself to risk because of lack of diversification
So you may want to invest in a double-exempt bond fund
Invest in a low-cost one like Vanguard California Tax-Free
But unless you can find a low-cost double-exempt municipal bond fund, you probably don't want to invest in double-exempt bond fund
Most double-exempt municipal bond funds are sold with high sales loads
The sales load usually eats up any advantage you gain from having a double-exempt bond
Here's a better strategy if you live in a small state where you can't find low-cost double-exempt bond funds
Satisfy yourself with the savings from investing in a low-cost single-exempt fund
Federal income tax rates are much higher than state-income tax rates
Or, if you have perhaps $100,000 or more to invest, create your own diversified portfolio of municipal bonds
Municipal bond mistake
Investing in a double-exempt fund in a state with no state income tax
Example
Don't invest in a Texas double-exempt bond fund
No higher equivalent yield since no Texas income tax
Lack of diversification exposes you to risk if the Texas economy goes down
Never put municipal bonds inside of a retirement account
If you place municipal bonds in a retirement account, you'll get a low yield and no tax advantages
In fact you'll have to pay taxes later since all earnings on retirement account money are subject to taxation